Winners of the 2004 Middle-Earth Fanfiction Awards
| Adventure | Author | 1st | The Battle of the Black Gate Award | Scribe | |
| Adventure | Author | 2nd | The Battle of the Pelennor Fields Award | Lindelea | |
| Adventure | Author | 3rd | The Battle of Helm's Deep Award | Legorfilinde | |
| Adventure | Pre-LOTR | 1st | The Battle of the Black Gate Award | Elflings | CC |
| Adventure | Pre-LOTR | 2nd | The Battle of the Pelennor Fields Award | Icicle Cream | Khylea |
| Adventure | Pre-LOTR | 3rd | The Battle of Helm's Deep Award | Betrayal | Cassia and Sio |
| Adventure | 1st | The Battle of the Black Gate Award | The Rebel | Lindelea | |
| Adventure | 2nd | The Battle of the Pelennor Fields Award | The Patient | Scribe | |
| Adventure | 3rd | The Battle of Helm's Deep Award | Wind and Fire | Adi | |
| Crossover | Author | 1st | The Pirates of the Caribbean Award | Altariel | |
| Crossover | Author | 2nd | The Hidalgo Award | Fileg & Flick | |
| Crossover | Author | 3rd | The Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade Award | Eledhwen | |
| Crossover | 1st | The Pirates of the Caribbean Award | Spirits of the House | Altariel | |
| Crossover | 2nd | The Hidalgo Award | Kings of the Sea | Eledhwen | |
| Crossover | 3rd | The Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade Award | The Corsair Papers | Fileg & Flick | |
| Drama | Romance | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | The Paths of Lorien | CC |
| Drama | Romance | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | In The Silence Of Our Hearts | Eresse |
| Drama | Romance | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Forbidden Fruit | Eresse |
| Drama | Pre-WOTR | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | A Family Trait | Marnie |
| Drama | Pre-WOTR | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | All These Wore Wings | fileg |
| Drama | Pre-WOTR | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Small Soldiers | Cori Lannam |
| Drama | Post-WOTR | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | The Last Grey Ship | ErinRua |
| Drama | Post-WOTR | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Perchance to Dream | M. N. Theis |
| Drama | Post-WOTR | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Shards of Time | AL Milton |
| Drama | Poetry | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | The Vain Songs | Nol |
| Drama | Poetry | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | From Fangorn Forest to Helm's Deep, Canto I The Forest | Chathol-linn |
| Drama | Poetry | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | The Day the Sun Didn't Rise | Tinni |
| Drama | LOTR | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | Pippin's Crucible | Pearl Took |
| Drama | LOTR | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Wizard | M. Sebasky |
| Drama | LOTR | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Ashes, East Wind, Hope that Rises | ErinRua |
| Drama | Incomplete | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | While We Dwelt in Fear | Pearl Took |
| Drama | Incomplete | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | The Captain's Last Gift | Lady Aranel |
| Drama | Incomplete | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Marinus Stiria | bryn_bnw |
| Drama | Gap-filler | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | A Silence Covered in Stone | Zimraphel |
| Drama | Gap-filler | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | The Fire Sermon | Altariel |
| Drama | Gap-filler | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Father and Sons | Dwimordene |
| Drama | Drabble | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | The Silent Street | Lindelea |
| Drama | Drabble | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Dernhelm's Ride | Lindelea |
| Drama | Drabble | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Alone | Oakenshield |
| Drama | Author Poetry | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | Chathol-linn | |
| Drama | Author Poetry | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Nol | |
| Drama | Author Poetry | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Naresha | |
| Drama | Author Drabble | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | Lindelea | |
| Drama | Author Drabble | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Oakenshield | |
| Drama | Author Drabble | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Alexcat | |
| Drama | Author | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | Dwimordene | |
| Drama | Author | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Ithilien | |
| Drama | Author | 3rd | The Nimrodel and Amroth Award | Pearl Took | |
| Drama | 1st | The Turin Turambar Award | Standards | Dwimordene | |
| Drama | 2nd | The Frodo Baggins Award | To Sing of War | Avon | |
| Drama | 3rd | The Frodo Baggins Award | Following the Other Wizard | jodancingtree | |
| Elves | Vignette | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | A Fool's Hope | Thundera Tiger |
| Elves | Vignette | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Rose Riddle | Stultiloquentia |
| Elves | Vignette | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Dinner Guests | Salsify |
| Elves | Silmarillion | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | The Wisdom of Isildur | Marnie |
| Elves | Silmarillion | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Henen | Larien Elengasse |
| Elves | Silmarillion | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Speak, Friend, and Enter | Thevina Finduilas |
| Elves | Romance | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Of Leaves of Gold and Petals Red: A Faery Tale | Ithilwen |
| Elves | Romance | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Meldir: At First Sight | Eresse |
| Elves | Romance | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | With Friends Like These | Eresse |
| Elves | Post-WOTR | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | The Green Knight | Le Rouret |
| Elves | Post-WOTR | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Of Pipes and Poetry | Thevina Finduilas |
| Elves | Post-WOTR | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | War Dust | Earmire |
| Elves | Incomplete | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Dawn Twilight | Viv |
| Elves | Incomplete | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Oak and Willow | Marnie |
| Elves | Incomplete | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Wayland The Smith | Jilian Baade |
| Elves | Drabble | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Untitled (Mirkwood) | Wild Iris |
| Elves | Drabble | 2nd | The Imladris Award | I Hear the Stones Lament | Avon |
| Elves | Drabble | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Longing | Dwimordene |
| Elves | Author Vignette | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Thundera Tiger | |
| Elves | Author Vignette | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Sphinx | |
| Elves | Author Vignette | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Stultiloquentia | |
| Elves | Author Drabble | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Wild Iris | |
| Elves | Author Drabble | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Avon | |
| Elves | Author Drabble | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Dwimordene | |
| Elves | Author | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Marnie | |
| Elves | Author | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Dwimordene | |
| Elves | Author | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Thevina Finduilas | |
| Elves | 1st | The Lothlorien Award | Across Dark Waters | Zimraphel | |
| Elves | 2nd | The Imladris Award | Gofi and the Balrog | Levade | |
| Elves | 3rd | The Grey Havens Award | Battle of the Golden Wood | Marnie | |
| Hobbits | The Lord of the Rings | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Bedside Chatter | Silvermoon Lady |
| Hobbits | The Lord of the Rings | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | The Conspiracy of Hobbits | Dreamflower |
| Hobbits | The Lord of the Rings | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | Riding the Nightmare | Budgielover |
| Hobbits | Pre-WotR | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Legacy | Anglachel |
| Hobbits | Pre-WotR | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | The Shaping of Samwise | Jodancingtree |
| Hobbits | Pre-WotR | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | River Stones | Jeodo Brandybuck |
| Hobbits | Post-WOTR | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Reckoning | Aratlithiel |
| Hobbits | Post-WOTR | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | A Crate of Lemons | ShireDweller |
| Hobbits | Post-WOTR | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | Garden Plot | ShireDweller |
| Hobbits | Poetry | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | The Lay of Peregrin Took | Llinos |
| Hobbits | Poetry | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | Shire Songbook | Lindelea |
| Hobbits | Poetry | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | Old Will Whitfoot | Tanaqui, co-written with Marta |
| Hobbits | Drabble | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Resting Places | Marigold |
| Hobbits | Drabble | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | Mother Gamgee | Marigold |
| Hobbits | Drabble | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | Then and Now | Marigold |
| Hobbits | Author Poetry | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Llinos | |
| Hobbits | Author Poetry | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | Lindelea | |
| Hobbits | Author Poetry | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | White Gull | |
| Hobbits | Author Drabble | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Marigold | |
| Hobbits | Author Drabble | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | Alexcat | |
| Hobbits | Author | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Silvermoon Lady | |
| Hobbits | Author | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | Lindelea | |
| Hobbits | Author | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | ShireDweller | |
| Hobbits | 1st | The Mayor of Hobbiton Award | Sam's Rose | jodancingtree | |
| Hobbits | 2nd | The Master of Buckland Award | A Path With No Returning | Citrine | |
| Hobbits | 3rd | The Thain of the Great Smials Award | Corrected!Of Dwarvish Ale and the Fairer Sex (Also: Recollections by Silvermoon Lady)* | Ariel | |
| Horror | Author | 1st | The Morgoth Bauglir Award | Watcherchild | |
| Horror | Author | 2nd | The Eye of Sauron Award | Zimraphel | |
| Horror | Author | 3rd | The Witch-King of Angmar Award | Ainaechoiriel | |
| Horror | 1st | The Morgoth Bauglir Award | The Lure of the Darkness | Ainaechoiriel | |
| Horror | 2nd | The Eye of Sauron Award | Coavalta | Zimraphel | |
| Horror | 3rd | The Witch-King of Angmar Award | The Truth of Ugliness | Watcherchild | |
| Humor | Romance | 1st | The Tom Bombadil Award | Home for the Holidays by Elladan son of Elrond | Claudi007 |
| Humor | Romance | 2nd | The Bilbo Baggins Award | How I Spent My Summer Vacation | Claudi007 |
| Humor | Romance | 3rd | The Barliman Butterbur Award | My Hairy Prisoner | BittenBuggy |
| Humor | Parody | 1st | The Tom Bombadil Award | Boromir: The Owner's Guide and Maintenance Manual | Theresa Green |
| Humor | Parody | 2nd | The Bilbo Baggins Award | Mairisuweniel Does Minas Tirith | Viv |
| Humor | Parody | 3rd | The Barliman Butterbur Award | Nine Men And A Little Lady | Kielle |
| Humor | Author | 1st | The Tom Bombadil Award | Claudi007 | |
| Humor | Author | 2nd | The Bilbo Baggins Award | CNell | |
| Humor | Author | 3rd | The Barliman Butterbur Award | Bryn (aka bryn_bnw) | |
| Humor | Alternate Universe | 1st | The Bilbo Baggins Award | T'was the Night Before Helm's Deep | Erin's Daughter |
| Humor | Alternate Universe | 2nd | The Tom Bombadil Award | The Story of Legolas and Enoreth | CNell |
| Humor | Alternate Universe | 3rd | The Barliman Butterbur Award | The Fanfic Lounge: The Lord of the Rings | CNell |
| Humor | 1st | The Tom Bombadil Award | Frogs | Lindelea | |
| Humor | 2nd | The Bilbo Baggins Award | Of Dwarvish Ale and Battle Scars | Aratlithiel | |
| Humor | 3rd | The Barliman Butterbur Award | The Jewel in the Crown | Alawa | |
| Lord of the Rings | Vignette | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Repairs | Isabeau of Greenlea |
| Lord of the Rings | Vignette | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Sting | TreeHugger |
| Lord of the Rings | Vignette | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | A Gift for Pippin | Gwynnyd |
| Lord of the Rings | Poetry | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | All Ye Fellowship of Nine | Azalais |
| Lord of the Rings | Poetry | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Tickle the Ranger | Alawa |
| Lord of the Rings | Poetry | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | Goldberry's Song | Vulgarweed |
| Lord of the Rings | Incomplete | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Recaptured! Ch. 1-92, Recaptured! Ch. 93-x | Llinos |
| Lord of the Rings | Incomplete | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Messages | Shakes |
| Lord of the Rings | Incomplete | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | Lie Down in Darkness, Rise Up from the Ash | Dwimordene |
| Lord of the Rings | Gondor | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Queen's Gambit | A L Milton |
| Lord of the Rings | Gondor | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | All of Them Together | Fileg |
| Lord of the Rings | Gondor | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | As Truly as the Arrow Flies | Fileg |
| Lord of the Rings | Drabble | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | I See the Moon, and the Moon Sees Me | Lindelea |
| Lord of the Rings | Drabble | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | That Which is Fairest | Elana |
| Lord of the Rings | Drabble | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | The Stone Tree | LKK |
| Lord of the Rings | Cross-cultural | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Those Who Remain | Marnie |
| Lord of the Rings | Cross-cultural | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Horses and Verses | Altariel and Isabeau |
| Lord of the Rings | Cross-cultural | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | I Return | Coriel |
| Lord of the Rings | Vignette | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Isabeau of Greenlea | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Vignette | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Azalais | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Vignette | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | Chris | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Poetry | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Alawa | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Poetry | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Fileg | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Poetry | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | Elvenesse | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Drabble | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Lindelea | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Drabble | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | LKK | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author Drabble | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | Elana | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Dwimordene | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | Fileg | |
| Lord of the Rings | Author | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | Zimraphel | |
| Lord of the Rings | 1st | The Fellowship fo the Ring Award | Aglarond | ErinRua | |
| Lord of the Rings | 2nd | The Two Towers Award | The Gift of Iluvatar | Ariel | |
| Lord of the Rings | 3rd | The Return of the King Award | A Different Kind of Sacrifice | Suzene Campos | |
| Men | Post-WOTR | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Light Lingering | Earmire/Nol |
| Men | Post-WOTR | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | Missing | Firerose |
| Men | Post-WOTR | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | The Endless Knot | E.M Theis |
| Men | Poetry | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Home by Morning | Fileg |
| Men | Poetry | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | An Elegy for Elfhild | Alawa |
| Men | Poetry | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | Ascension | Fileg |
| Men | Incomplete | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Blackbow | Isabeau of Greenlea |
| Men | Incomplete | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | The Queen's Orc | jodancingtree |
| Men | Incomplete | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | Orcbrat | The Lauderdale |
| Men | Gondor | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Death by Water | Altariel |
| Men | Gondor | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | A Pale Light Lingering | Altariel |
| Men | Gondor | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | Singer by the shore | Beth Winter |
| Men | Author Poetry | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Fileg | |
| Men | Author Poetry | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | RennWench and Alstaria | |
| Men | Author Poetry | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | Alawa | |
| Men | Author | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Altariel | |
| Men | Author | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | Celandine Brandybuck | |
| Men | Author | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | Shadow975 | |
| Men | 1st | The Faithful of Numenor Award | Night in Hollin | Nancy Brooke | |
| Men | 2nd | The Kings of Gondor and Arnor Award | Captain, My Captain | Isabeau of Greenlea | |
| Men | 3rd | The Ruling Stewards Award | Through A Glass | Altariel | |
| Mystery | Author | 1st | The Shadows of Cuivienen Award | meckinock | |
| Mystery | Author | 2nd | The Pukelmen Award | Levade | |
| Mystery | Author | 3rd | The Barrow-Wight Award | Werecat | |
| Mystery | 1st | The Shadows of Cuivienen Award | That Way | Werecat | |
| Mystery | 2nd | The Pukelmen Award | The Next Step | Watcherchild | |
| Mystery | 3rd | The Barrow-Wight Award | Shades of the Immortal | Levade | |
| Numenor | Author | 1st | The Elros, Son of Earendil Award | Zimraphel | |
| Numenor | Author | 2nd | The Tar-Palantir Award | Nessime | |
| Numenor | Author | 3rd | The Tar-Miriel Award | Jen Littlebottom | |
| Numenor | 1st | The Elros, Son of Earendil Award | The Sinking of Numenor | Jen Littlebottom | |
| Numenor | 2nd | The Tar-Palantir Award | The Eleventh Hour | Zimraphel | |
| Numenor | 3rd | The Tar-Miriel Award | Aglarrama | Zimraphel | |
| Orcs | Author | 1st | The Barad-dur Award | Igenlode Wordsmith | |
| Orcs | Author | 2nd | The Minas Morgul Award | Lindelea | |
| Orcs | Author | 3rd | The Orthanc Award | Virvatuli | |
| Orcs | 1st | The Barad-dur Award | The Eyes Of An Enemy | shadow975 | |
| Orcs | 2nd | The Minas Morgul Award | Orc Patrol | Igenlode Wordsmith | |
| Orcs | 3rd | The Orthanc Award | Hunger | Nath | |
| Rohan | Author | 1st | The Theoden Award | Nessime | |
| Rohan | Author | 2nd | The Eomer Award | Alawa | |
| Rohan | Author | 3rd | The Eowyn Award | Forodwaith | |
| Rohan | 1st | The Theoden Award | Promises to Keep | Nessime | |
| Rohan | 2nd | The Eomer Award | For the Dark | Forodwaith | |
| Rohan | 3rd | The Eowyn Award | Complicated Allies | Sun Queen | |
| Romance | Rivendell | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | To My Shining Light | Oakenshield |
| Romance | Rivendell | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Underestimated | Enismirdal |
| Romance | Rivendell | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Vanilla Cream | Kharessa Bloodrose |
| Romance | Poetry | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Love me, Urgren | Werecat |
| Romance | Poetry | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Courtship of the Evenstar | White Gull |
| Romance | Poetry | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | A Hole Possessed | Marta |
| Romance | Incomplete | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Elanor's Revenge | Julie & Fianna |
| Romance | Incomplete | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | The Cursed Queen of Angmar | KhazarKhum |
| Romance | Incomplete | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | At Last | Jennifer Lee & Ellbee |
| Romance | Hobbits | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | A Little Night Music | Ariel |
| Romance | Hobbits | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Just to be With You | Pervinca |
| Romance | Hobbits | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Falling Stars | SoundofHorns |
| Romance | Gondor | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Simple Gifts | Thevina Finduilas |
| Romance | Gondor | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Speaking of Love... | Dwimordene |
| Romance | Featuring Legolas | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Eternally | Jennifer Lee & Ellbee |
| Romance | Featuring Legolas | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | In the Midst of Adversity | Maram68 |
| Romance | Featuring Legolas | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | To Have and To Hold | Lady Rheena |
| Romance | Featuring Haldir | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Why? | RennWench |
| Romance | Featuring Haldir | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Amarie & Haldir: Paths of Destiny | Julie |
| Romance | Featuring Haldir | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Perfectly Happy | Alexcat |
| Romance | Faramir/Eowyn | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | The Influence of Kindred Desires | Tanaqui |
| Romance | Faramir/Eowyn | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Knight's Service/Later | Tanaqui |
| Romance | Faramir/Eowyn | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Snowdrops and Bluebells | Regina |
| Romance | Author Poetry | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Naresha | |
| Romance | Author Poetry | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Werecat | |
| Romance | Author Poetry | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Marta | |
| Romance | Author | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Tyellas | |
| Romance | Author | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Julie & Fianna | |
| Romance | Author | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Mirasaui | |
| Romance | 1st | The Luthien and Beren Award | Quickening | Tyellas | |
| Romance | 2nd | The Tuor and Idril Award | Spring In Imladris | CC | |
| Romance | 3rd | The Aragorn and Arwen Award | Swept Away | Larian Elensar | |
| The Hobbit | Author | 1st | The Shire Award | TreeHugger | |
| The Hobbit | Author | 2nd | The Mirkwood Award | Marta | |
| The Hobbit | Author | 3rd | The Lonely Mountain Award | Gecco | |
| The Hobbit | 1st | The Shire Award | In the Hall of the Wood Elf King | TreeHugger | |
| The Hobbit | 2nd | The Mirkwood Award | Estel and the Hobbit | Eledhwen | |
| The Hobbit | 3rd | The Lonely Mountain Award | The Emblem You Chose | Wild Iris | |
| The Silmarillion | Second Age | 1st | The Ainulindale Award | A Last Reckoning | Nol |
| The Silmarillion | Second Age | 2nd | The Valaquenta Award | Oath Renewed | Inglor |
| The Silmarillion | Second Age | 3rd | The Akallabeth Award | Mortal Shores | Vorondis |
| The Silmarillion | Romance | 1st | The Ainulindale Award | Fell Fire | Finch |
| The Silmarillion | Romance | 2nd | The Valaquenta Award | Taming the Wildflower | Sulriel |
| The Silmarillion | Romance | 3rd | The Akallabeth Award | The Unforgettable Fire | Ithilwen |
| The Silmarillion | Incomplete | 1st | The Ainulindale Award | A Veiled Light | Andreth |
| The Silmarillion | Incomplete | 2nd | The Valaquenta Award | Beneath the Light | Mouse |
| The Silmarillion | Incomplete | 3rd | The Akallabeth Award | Fated | Nimrodel Jen |
| The Silmarillion | First Age | 1st | The Ainulindale Award | Finrod's Oath | Jmac |
| The Silmarillion | First Age | 2nd | The Valaquenta Award | Slouching Toward Gondolin | Fileg |
| The Silmarillion | First Age | 3rd | The Akallabeth Award | Dark Forge | Ithilwen |
| The Silmarillion | Author | 1st | The Ainulindale Award | Zimraphel | |
| The Silmarillion | Author | 2nd | The Valaquenta Award | Nol | |
| The Silmarillion | Author | 3rd | The Akallabeth Award | Jmac | |
| The Silmarillion | 1st | The Ainulindale Award | Gold Like Tears | Zimraphel | |
| The Silmarillion | 2nd | The Valaquenta Award | If Women had Ruled Middle Earth | Mouse | |
| The Silmarillion | 3rd | The Akallabeth Award | Not for Pride Alone | Zimraphel |
*The award was first given to Recollections then it was noticed that "Of Dwarvish Ale...." actually won by 2 points. It was decided not to take the award away from the author of Recollections, but to correct the listing to show that "Of Dwarvish Ale...." actually won. We hope to avoid all such mistakes in the future and apologize for any hurt feelings this may have caused.